Pink Lip Matte Ratings
Kwame Johnson
| 07-07-2026

· Fashion team
Welcome, Lykkers! Pink lipstick is one of those beauty staples I can never have too many of. Whether I'm going for a fresh everyday look or something a little more polished, a beautiful pink lip always seems to complete the vibe.
Recently, I reached for two lip mattes that quickly earned a spot in my makeup pouch. They each have a different charm, but both left me with a great impression.
1. L'Oréal x Elie Saab Rouge Signature 121 — 8/10
The first thing I noticed was how elegant this pink shade looked. It has a soft, sophisticated tone that works beautifully for everyday wear, but it also feels dressy enough for special occasions. The matte finish looks smooth, and the lightweight formula makes it comfortable to wear for hours.
I gave it an 8/10 because it performs really well overall. The color applies evenly and feels almost weightless on my lips, which I love. However, after eating or drinking, I usually need a quick touch-up to bring back the original intensity. Even so, it's still one of those lipsticks I reach for when I want an effortlessly polished look.
2. Marshwillow Velvet Smoothie Watermelon Breeze — 8/10
Watermelon Breeze instantly gives my makeup a fresher, softer appearance. The pink shade has a youthful vibe that brightens my face without looking overdone, making it an easy choice for casual days.
I also rated this one 8/10 because the formula feels pleasantly velvety and glides across my lips without looking patchy. It creates a comfortable matte finish that doesn't feel overly dry. The only reason it didn't score higher is that I find myself reapplying it after several hours to keep the color looking its best. Still, it's a lovely lipstick whenever I'm in the mood for a natural pink look with a soft finish.
These two pink lip mattes may share the same rating, but they shine in different ways. One leans toward timeless elegance, while the other brings a playful and effortless vibe. That's exactly why I enjoy having both in my collection. Sometimes the perfect lip color isn't about choosing the better product—it's about finding the one that matches my mood that day. Which pink style would you reach for first?