Good Day, Lykkers! Mascara can completely change the mood of a makeup look. Some days call for dramatic, inky lashes, while others are all about a softer, lifted finish.

I’ve been looking at three popular options that each bring something different to the lash routine, from budget-friendly definition to that classic curled effect.

1. e.l.f. Cosmetics Lash XTNDR Mascara — $8.00

Shade: Pitch Black

For an affordable everyday mascara, the e.l.f. Lash XTNDR is hard to ignore at just $8. The pitch-black shade gives lashes a more defined appearance, making the eyes look instantly more noticeable without needing a complicated makeup routine. I like the idea of keeping a mascara like this around for quick makeup days when there is no desire to spend forever working on the lashes. The deeper color also pairs nicely with simple eyeliner or a neutral eyeshadow look.

2. Lancôme Définicils Defining and Lengthening Mascara — $34.00

Shade: Black

Lancôme Définicils takes a more classic approach, focusing on definition and length. The black shade gives the lashes a polished finish that works beautifully with both natural makeup and more dressed-up looks. For anyone who prefers separated, defined-looking lashes rather than an overly dramatic effect, this one feels like a timeless choice. The slim, refined lash look can make eye makeup appear neat and intentional.

3. Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara — $29.00

Shade: Black

Roller Lash is the pick I’d reach for when curl and lift are the main priorities. The concept is all about giving the lashes a more lifted appearance, which can make the eyes look brighter and more awake. It also works nicely when the rest of the makeup is kept simple. A little mascara, some brow definition, and a touch of lip color can already create a put-together look.

Three mascaras, three different personalities. e.l.f. keeps things affordable and easy, Lancôme brings classic definition, while Benefit focuses on that lifted, curled effect. Picking a favorite really depends on the lash look you want that day—defined, lengthened, or lifted?