When it comes to makeup tools, I’m happy to splurge on brushes—but beauty sponges are a different story.

Since I replace them about once a month, I always reach for drugstore options. Over time, I’ve realized that affordable sponges often perform just as well as high-end ones, sometimes even better. These two have been repurchased more times than I can count for a reason.

1. Real Techniques Makeup Sponge – A True Classic

The Real Techniques sponge is a longtime favorite and a solid alternative to higher-end options. At around $7, it blends foundation and concealer effortlessly, especially under the eyes where I want the most seamless finish. I love that it comes with a protective case, making it perfect for travel.

2. e.l.f. Halo Glow Pinkie Puffs – Small but Mighty

These pinkie puffs are only $4 and seriously impressive. I use them with both loose and pressed powders to set my under-eyes, and they give such a clean, smooth finish. The size makes them easy to control, and they’re ideal for precise powder application.

You don’t need to spend a lot to get great makeup tools. These drugstore sponges are affordable, reliable, and deliver flawless results every time. They’ve earned a permanent spot in my routine—and my repurchase list.