My makeup can be almost nonexistent, but a good lipstick still makes me feel more put together. I usually gravitate toward shades I can wear without spending ten minutes figuring out the rest of my look.

NARS Fast Love and Kevyn Aucoin Roserin caught my attention for different reasons, and the finishes are a big part of the appeal.

1. NARS Afterglow Lipstick – Fast Love

The lipstick I’d throw into my bag without a second thought. Some mornings, I just want to get ready and leave. No complicated lip liner, no perfectly blended eye makeup. That’s when a comfortable lipstick like NARS Afterglow makes sense to me. The formula has a balm-like feel, which appeals to anyone who prefers a softer finish over a dry, matte look. Fast Love is a shade I’d pair with a little blush and fresh skin for everyday plans.

2. Kevyn Aucoin Unforgettable Lipstick – Shine in Roserin

For days when a little extra shine feels right. Roserin gives me a reason to take a different approach to my makeup. The shine-focused finish of Kevyn Aucoin’s Unforgettable Lipstick has a dressier feel, especially when paired with softly defined eyes and a simple base.

I’d wear it when meeting friends for dinner or getting ready for an occasion that calls for something a little more polished. Glossy-looking lips can bring life to a minimal makeup look, so I wouldn’t feel the need to add much else.

I don’t think every lipstick needs to be a statement piece. Sometimes I want something comfortable that works with whatever I’m wearing; other times, I want that shiny finish that makes my makeup feel more complete. NARS Fast Love fits the first mood, while Kevyn Aucoin Roserin suits the second. Having both options means I can decide at the last minute—and that’s usually how my favorite makeup looks come together anyway.