My makeup can be super minimal, but I rarely skip fixing my brows. A few little strokes can make my face look more put together, even when I’m wearing nothing but tinted lip balm and a touch of blush.

Lately, I’ve been eyeing two popular brow pencils in Medium Brown, and honestly, choosing between them wouldn’t be easy!

1. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz Precision Eyebrow Pencil – Medium Brown

Some products become popular for a reason, and ABH Brow Wiz is one I’ve been curious about for a while. The ultra-fine pencil tip is designed for precise application, making it appealing when I want to fill in sparse spots without creating a blocky brow. My favorite way to do brows is to work slowly, using short, hair-like strokes instead of drawing one thick line. I’d focus on the areas that look a little uneven, then use the spoolie to blend everything together. The goal is a naturally fuller look, not brows that look stamped onto my face.

2. Charlotte Tilbury Brow Cheat Hair-Like Eyebrow Pencil – Medium Brown

Charlotte Tilbury always gives me that glamorous beauty-counter feeling, but I also appreciate makeup that can look effortless. The Brow Cheat pencil caught my attention because its hair-like application is designed to create natural-looking definition. I’d use it to add little strokes through sparse areas and give my arches a more balanced shape. I love brows that look softly structured rather than overly perfect, so a precise pencil like this sounds right up my alley.

Beautiful brows don’t have to be perfectly identical; sometimes, a little natural texture makes them look even better. So, which would you choose for your makeup bag: Anastasia Beverly Hills or Charlotte Tilbury?